wip(LRA): new simplex implementation

src/arith/lra/simplex2.ml

@@ -25,6 +25,7 @@ end
 
 module type S = sig
   module V : VAR
+  module V_map : CCMap.S with type key = V.t
 
   type num = Q.t (** Numbers *)
 
@@ -38,24 +39,72 @@ module type S = sig
       rhs: num;
     }
 
+    val leq : V.t -> num -> t
+    val lt : V.t -> num -> t
+    val geq : V.t -> num -> t
+    val gt : V.t -> num -> t
+
     val pp : t Fmt.printer
   end
 
+  module Subst : sig
+    type t = num V_map.t
+    val pp : t Fmt.printer
+    val to_string : t -> string
+  end
+
   type t
 
   val create : unit -> t
   (** Create a new simplex. *)
 
+  val push_level : t -> unit
+
+  val pop_levels : t -> int -> unit
+
   val define : t -> V.t -> (num * V.t) list -> unit
   (** Define a basic variable in terms of other variables.
       This is useful to "name" a linear expression and get back a variable
       that can be used in a {!Constraint.t} *)
+
+  type unsat_cert = {
+    cert_bounds: (num * V.lit) list;
+    cert_defs: (V.t * (num * V.t) list) list; (* definitions used *)
+  }
+
+  module Unsat_cert : sig
+    type t = unsat_cert
+    val pp : t Fmt.printer
+  end
+
+  exception E_unsat of Unsat_cert.t
+
+  val add_constraint : t -> Constraint.t -> V.lit -> unit
+  (** Add a constraint to the simplex.
+      @raise Unsat if it's immediately obvious that this is not satisfiable. *)
+
+  val check_exn : t -> unit
+  (** Check the whole simplex for satisfiability.
+      @raise Unsat if the constraints are not satisfiable. *)
+
+  type result =
+    | Sat of Subst.t
+    | Unsat of Unsat_cert.t
+
+  val check : t -> result
+  (** Call {!check_exn} and return a model or a proof of unsat. *)
 end
 
+(* TODO(optim): page 14, paragraph 2: we could detect which variables occur in no
+   atom after preprocessing; then these variables can be "inlined" (removed
+   by Gaussian elimination) as a preprocessing step, and this removes one column
+   and maybe one row if it was basic. *)
+
 module Make(Var: VAR)
   : S with module V = Var
 = struct
   module V = Var
+  module V_map = CCMap.Make(Var)
 
   type num = Q.t (** Numbers *)
 
@@ -72,6 +121,20 @@ module Make(Var: VAR)
     let pp out (self:t) =
       Fmt.fprintf out "(@[%a %s@ %a@])" V.pp self.lhs
         (Op.to_string self.op) Q.pp_print self.rhs
+
+    let leq lhs rhs = {lhs;rhs;op=Op.Leq}
+    let lt lhs rhs = {lhs;rhs;op=Op.Lt}
+    let geq lhs rhs = {lhs;rhs;op=Op.Geq}
+    let gt lhs rhs = {lhs;rhs;op=Op.Gt}
+  end
+
+  module Subst = struct
+    type t = num V_map.t
+    let pp out (self:t) : unit =
+      let pp_pair out (v,n) =
+        Fmt.fprintf out "(@[%a := %a@])" V.pp v Q.pp_print n in
+      Fmt.fprintf out "{@[%a@]}" (Fmt.iter pp_pair) (V_map.to_iter self)
+    let to_string = Fmt.to_string pp
   end
 
   (** An extended rational, used to introduce ε so we can use strict
@@ -91,19 +154,24 @@ module Make(Var: VAR)
     let zero : t = {base=Q.zero; eps_factor=Q.zero}
 
     let[@inline] make base eps_factor : t = {base; eps_factor}
+    let[@inline] make_q x = make x Q.zero
     let[@inline] base t = t.base
     let[@inline] eps_factor t = t.eps_factor
-    let[@inline] mul k e = make Q.(k * e.base) Q.(k * e.eps_factor)
-    let[@inline] sum e1 e2 = make Q.(e1.base + e2.base) Q.(e1.eps_factor + e2.eps_factor)
+    let[@inline] ( * ) k e = make Q.(k * e.base) Q.(k * e.eps_factor)
+    let[@inline] ( / ) e k = make Q.(e.base / k) Q.(e.eps_factor / k)
+    let[@inline] (+) e1 e2 = make Q.(e1.base + e2.base) Q.(e1.eps_factor + e2.eps_factor)
+    let[@inline] (-) e1 e2 = make Q.(e1.base - e2.base) Q.(e1.eps_factor - e2.eps_factor)
     let[@inline] compare e1 e2 = match Q.compare e1.base e2.base with
       | 0 -> Q.compare e1.eps_factor e2.eps_factor
       | x -> x
 
-    let[@inline] lt a b = compare a b < 0
-    let[@inline] gt a b = compare a b > 0
+    let[@inline] (<) a b = compare a b < 0
+    let[@inline] (<=) a b = compare a b <= 0
+    let[@inline] (>) a b = compare a b > 0
+    let[@inline] (>=) a b = compare a b >= 0
 
-    let[@inline] min x y = if compare x y <= 0 then x else y
-    let[@inline] max x y = if compare x y >= 0 then x else y
+    let[@inline] min x y = if x <= y then x else y
+    let[@inline] max x y = if x >= y then x else y
 
     let[@inline] evaluate (epsilon:Q.t) (e:t) : Q.t = Q.(e.base + epsilon * e.eps_factor)
 
@@ -115,9 +183,556 @@ module Make(Var: VAR)
           Q.pp_print (base e) Q.pp_print (eps_factor e)
   end
 
-  type t = unit
+  type var_idx = int
 
-  let create () : t = ()
+  (** {2 Matrix}
+    The matrix [A] from the paper, with m rows and n columns.
+    - m is the number of basic variables (defined in terms of non-basic variables)
+    - n is the total number of variables, basic and non-basic.
 
-  let define _ = assert false (* TODO *)
+    The invariant that the simplex maintains at all times is that [Ax = 0],
+    where [x] is the vector of values of all variables (basic and non-basic).
+  *)
+
+  module Matrix : sig
+    type t
+
+    val create : unit -> t
+
+    val pp : t Fmt.printer
+    val to_string : t -> string
+
+    val n_rows : t -> int
+    val n_cols : t -> int
+
+    val add_column : t -> unit
+    (** Add a non-basic variable (only adds a column) *)
+
+    val add_row_and_column : t -> int
+    (** Add a basic variable. returns the row index. *)
+
+    val get_row_var_idx : t -> int -> var_idx
+    (** Index of the basic variable for row [i] *)
+
+    val set_row_var_idx : t -> int -> var_idx -> unit
+    (** Set index of the basic variable for row [i] *)
+
+    val get : t -> int -> int -> num
+
+    val set : t -> int -> int -> num -> unit
+
+    val add : t -> int -> int -> num -> unit
+
+    val mult : t -> int -> int -> num -> unit
+  end = struct
+    type row = {
+      mutable var_idx: var_idx;
+      cols: num Vec.t;
+    }
+    type t = {
+      rows: row Vec.t
+    }
+
+    let create() : t = {rows=Vec.create()}
+
+    let[@inline] n_rows self = Vec.size self.rows
+    let n_cols self =
+      if n_rows self=0 then 0
+      else Vec.size (Vec.get self.rows 0).cols
+
+    let pp out self =
+      Fmt.fprintf out "{@[<v>";
+      Vec.iteri (fun i row ->
+          Fmt.fprintf out "@[<hov2>%-5d: %a@]@," i
+            (Fmt.iter ~sep:(Fmt.return "@ ") Q.pp_print) (Vec.to_seq row.cols))
+        self.rows;
+      Fmt.fprintf out "@]}"
+    let to_string = Fmt.to_string pp
+
+    let add_column self =
+      Vec.iter (fun r -> Vec.push r.cols Q.zero) self.rows
+
+    let add_row_and_column self : int =
+      let n = n_rows self in
+      let j = n_cols self in
+      add_column self;
+      let row = {var_idx=j; cols=Vec.make (j+1) Q.zero} in
+      Vec.push self.rows row;
+      n
+
+    let[@inline] get_row_var_idx self i = (Vec.get self.rows i).var_idx
+    let[@inline] set_row_var_idx self i n = (Vec.get self.rows i).var_idx <- n
+
+    let[@inline] get self i j : num = Vec.get (Vec.get self.rows i).cols j
+
+    let[@inline] set self i j n : unit =
+      let r = Vec.get self.rows i in
+      Vec.set r.cols j n
+
+    (* add [n] to [m_ij] *)
+    let add self i j n : unit =
+      let r = Vec.get self.rows i in
+      Vec.set r.cols j Q.(Vec.get r.cols j + n)
+
+    (* multiply [m_ij] by [c] *)
+    let mult self i j c : unit =
+      let r = Vec.get self.rows i in
+      let n_j = Vec.get r.cols j in
+      if Q.sign n_j <> 0 then (
+        Vec.set r.cols j Q.(n_j * c)
+      )
+  end
+
+  type bound = {
+    b_val: erat;
+    b_lit: Var.lit;
+  }
+
+  type var_state = {
+    var: V.t;
+    mutable value: erat;
+    idx: int; (* index in {!t.vars} *)
+    mutable basic_idx: int; (* index of the row in the matrix, if any. -1 otherwise *)
+    mutable l_bound: bound option;
+    mutable u_bound: bound option;
+  }
+
+  module Var_state = struct
+    type t = var_state
+
+    let[@inline] is_basic (self:t) : bool = self.basic_idx >= 0
+    let[@inline] is_n_basic (self:t) : bool = self.basic_idx < 0
+    let pp out self =
+      Fmt.fprintf out "(@[var %a@ :basic %B@ :value %a@ :lbound %a@ :ubound %a@])"
+        Var.pp self.var (is_basic self) Erat.pp self.value
+        Fmt.(Dump.option (map (fun b->b.b_val) Erat.pp)) self.l_bound
+        Fmt.(Dump.option (map (fun b->b.b_val) Erat.pp)) self.u_bound
+  end
+
+  type t = {
+    matrix: Matrix.t;
+    vars: var_state Vec.t; (* index -> var with this index *)
+    mutable var_tbl: var_state V_map.t; (* var -> its state *)
+    bound_stack: (var_state * [`Upper|`Lower] * bound option) Backtrack_stack.t;
+  }
+
+  let push_level self : unit =
+    Backtrack_stack.push_level self.bound_stack
+
+  let pop_levels self n : unit =
+    Backtrack_stack.pop_levels self.bound_stack n
+      ~f:(fun (var, kind, bnd) ->
+          match kind with
+          | `Upper -> var.u_bound <- bnd
+          | `Lower -> var.l_bound <- bnd);
+    ()
+
+  let pp out (self:t) : unit =
+    Fmt.fprintf out "(@[simplex@ :vars %a@ :matrix %a@])"
+      (Vec.pp Var_state.pp) self.vars
+      Matrix.pp self.matrix
+
+  let[@inline] has_var_ (self:t) x : bool = V_map.mem x self.var_tbl
+  let[@inline] find_var_ (self:t) x : var_state =
+    try V_map.find x self.var_tbl
+    with Not_found -> Error.errorf "variable is not in the simplex" Var.pp x
+
+  let define (self:t) (x:V.t) (le:_ list) : unit =
+    assert (not (has_var_ self x));
+    Log.debugf 5 (fun k->k "(@[simplex.define@ %a@ :le %a@])"
+                     Var.pp x Fmt.(Dump.(list @@ pair Q.pp_print Var.pp)) le);
+    let n = Matrix.add_row_and_column self.matrix in
+    let vs = {
+      var=x; value=Erat.zero;
+      idx=Vec.size self.vars;
+      basic_idx=n;
+      l_bound=None;
+      u_bound=None;
+    } in
+    Vec.push self.vars vs;
+    self.var_tbl <- V_map.add x vs self.var_tbl;
+    (* set coefficients in the matrix's new row: [-x + le = 0] *)
+    Matrix.set self.matrix n vs.idx Q.minus_one;
+    List.iter
+      (fun (coeff,v2) ->
+         let vs2 = find_var_ self v2 in
+         Matrix.add self.matrix n vs2.idx coeff;
+      ) le;
+    ()
+
+  (* find the state for [x], or add [x] as a non-basic variable *)
+  let find_or_create_n_basic_var_ (self:t) (x:V.t) : var_state =
+    try V_map.find x self.var_tbl
+    with Not_found ->
+      Matrix.add_column self.matrix;
+      let vs = {
+        idx=Vec.size self.vars;
+        basic_idx= -1;
+        var=x;
+        l_bound=None;
+        u_bound=None;
+        value=Erat.zero;
+      } in
+      assert (Var_state.is_n_basic vs);
+      self.var_tbl <- V_map.add x vs self.var_tbl;
+      Vec.push self.vars vs;
+      vs
+
+  (* update the simplex so that non-basic [x] is now assigned value [n].
+     See page 14, figure 3.1.
+  *)
+  let update_n_basic (self:t) (x:var_state) (v:erat) : unit =
+    assert (Var_state.is_n_basic x);
+    let m = self.matrix in
+    let i = x.idx in
+
+    let diff = Erat.(v - x.value) in
+
+    for j=0 to Matrix.n_rows m - 1 do
+      let a_ji = Matrix.get m j i in
+      let x_j = Vec.get self.vars (Matrix.get_row_var_idx m j) in
+      assert (Var_state.is_basic x_j);
+      (* value of [x_j] by [a_ji * diff] *)
+      x_j.value <- Erat.(x_j.value + a_ji * diff);
+    done;
+    x.value <- v;
+    ()
+
+  (* pivot [x_i] (basic) and [x_j] (non-basic), setting value of [x_i]
+     to [v] at the same time.
+     See page 14, figure 3.1 *)
+  let pivot_and_update (self:t) (x_i:var_state) (x_j:var_state) (v:erat) : unit =
+    assert (Var_state.is_basic x_i);
+    assert (Var_state.is_n_basic x_j);
+    let m = self.matrix in
+    let a_ij = Matrix.get m x_i.basic_idx x_j.idx in
+    assert (Q.sign a_ij <> 0);
+    let theta = Erat.((v - x_i.value) / a_ij) in
+    x_i.value <- v;
+    x_j.value <- Erat.(x_j.value + theta);
+
+    for k=0 to Matrix.n_rows m-1 do
+      if k <> x_i.basic_idx then (
+        let x_k = Vec.get self.vars (Matrix.get_row_var_idx m k) in
+        let a_kj = Matrix.get m x_k.basic_idx x_j.idx in
+        x_k.value <- Erat.(x_k.value + a_kj * theta);
+      )
+    done;
+
+    (* now pivot the variables so that [x_j]'s coeff is -1 *)
+    let new_coeff = Q.(minus_one / a_ij) in
+    for k=0 to Matrix.n_cols m-1 do
+      Matrix.mult m x_i.idx k new_coeff;
+    done;
+    x_j.basic_idx <- x_i.basic_idx;
+    x_i.basic_idx <- -1;
+    Matrix.set_row_var_idx m x_j.basic_idx x_j.idx;
+
+    assert (Var_state.is_basic x_j);
+    assert (Var_state.is_n_basic x_i);
+
+    ()
+
+  type unsat_cert = {
+    cert_bounds: (num * V.lit) list;
+    cert_defs: (V.t * (num * V.t) list) list; (* definitions used *)
+  }
+
+  module Unsat_cert = struct
+    type t = unsat_cert
+
+    let pp out (self:t) =
+      let pp_bnd out (n,lit) =
+        Fmt.fprintf out "(@[%a@ coeff %a@])" V.pp_lit lit Q.pp_print n
+      in
+      Fmt.fprintf out "(@[cert@ :bounds %a@ :defs %a@])"
+        Fmt.(Dump.list pp_bnd) self.cert_bounds
+        Fmt.(Dump.list (Dump.pair V.pp (Dump.list (Dump.pair Q.pp_print V.pp)))) self.cert_defs
+
+    let mk ~defs ~bounds : t =
+      { cert_defs=defs; cert_bounds=bounds }
+  end
+
+  exception E_unsat of Unsat_cert.t
+
+  let add_constraint (self:t) (c:Constraint.t) (lit:V.lit) : unit =
+    let open Constraint in
+    let vs = find_or_create_n_basic_var_ self c.lhs in
+    let is_lower_bnd, new_bnd_val =
+      match c.op with
+      | Leq -> false, Erat.make_q c.rhs
+      | Lt -> false, Erat.make c.rhs Q.minus_one
+      | Geq -> true, Erat.make_q c.rhs
+      | Gt -> true, Erat.make c.rhs Q.one
+    in
+    let new_bnd = {b_val=new_bnd_val; b_lit=lit} in
+    if is_lower_bnd then (
+      begin match vs.l_bound, vs.u_bound with
+        | _, Some upper when Erat.(new_bnd.b_val > upper.b_val) ->
+          (* [b_val <= x <= upper], but [b_val > upper] *)
+          let cert = Unsat_cert.mk ~defs:[]
+              ~bounds:[(Q.one, upper.b_lit); (Q.one, lit)] in
+          raise (E_unsat cert)
+        | Some lower, _ when Erat.(lower.b_val >= new_bnd.b_val) ->
+          () (* subsumed by existing constraint, do nothing *)
+        | _ ->
+          (* save current bound *)
+          Backtrack_stack.push self.bound_stack (vs, `Lower, vs.l_bound);
+          vs.l_bound <- Some new_bnd;
+
+          if Var_state.is_n_basic vs &&
+             Erat.(vs.value < new_bnd.b_val) then (
+            (* line 5: need to update non-basic variable *)
+            update_n_basic self vs new_bnd.b_val
+          )
+      end
+    ) else (
+      begin match vs.l_bound, vs.u_bound with
+        | Some lower, _ when Erat.(new_bnd.b_val < lower.b_val) ->
+          (* [lower <= x <= b_val], but [b_val < lower] *)
+          let cert = Unsat_cert.mk ~defs:[]
+              ~bounds:[(Q.one, lower.b_lit); (Q.one, lit)] in
+          raise (E_unsat cert)
+        | _, Some upper when Erat.(upper.b_val <= new_bnd.b_val) ->
+          () (* subsumed *)
+        | _ ->
+          Backtrack_stack.push self.bound_stack (vs, `Upper, vs.u_bound);
+          vs.u_bound <- Some new_bnd;
+
+          if Var_state.is_n_basic vs &&
+             Erat.(vs.value > new_bnd.b_val) then (
+            (* line 5: need to update non-basic variable *)
+            update_n_basic self vs new_bnd.b_val
+          )
+      end
+    )
+
+  (* try to find basic variable that doesn't respect one of its bounds *)
+  let find_basic_var_ (self:t) : (var_state * [`Lower | `Upper] * bound) option =
+    let n = Matrix.n_rows self.matrix in
+    let rec aux i =
+      if i >= n then None
+      else (
+        let x_i = Vec.get self.vars (Matrix.get_row_var_idx self.matrix i) in
+        let v_i = x_i.value in
+        match x_i.l_bound, x_i.u_bound with
+        | Some l, _ when Erat.(l.b_val > v_i) -> Some (x_i, `Lower, l)
+        | _, Some u when Erat.(u.b_val < v_i) -> Some (x_i, `Upper, u)
+        | _ -> (aux[@tailcall]) (i+1)
+      )
+    in
+    aux 0
+
+  let find_n_basic_var_ (self:t) ~f : var_state option =
+    let rec aux j =
+      if j >= Vec.size self.vars then None
+      else (
+        let x_j = Vec.get self.vars j in
+        if Var_state.is_n_basic x_j && f x_j then Some x_j
+        else aux (j+1)
+      )
+    in
+    aux 0
+
+  (* true if [x.value < x.u_bound] *)
+  let has_upper_slack (x:var_state) : bool =
+    match x.u_bound with
+    | None -> true
+    | Some bnd -> Erat.(x.value < bnd.b_val)
+
+  (* true if [x.value > x.l_bound] *)
+  let has_lower_slack (x:var_state) : bool =
+    match x.l_bound with
+    | None -> true
+    | Some bnd -> Erat.(x.value > bnd.b_val)
+
+  (* make a certificate from the row of basic variable [x_i] which is outside
+     one of its bound, and whose row is tight on all non-basic variables *)
+  let cert_of_row_ (self:t) (x_i:var_state) ~is_lower : unsat_cert =
+    Log.debugf 50 (fun k->k "(@[simplex.cert-of-row[lower: %B]@ x_i=%a@ %a@])"
+                      is_lower Var_state.pp x_i pp self);
+    assert (Var_state.is_basic x_i);
+    (* TODO: store initial definition for each matrix row *)
+    let defs = [] in
+    let bounds = [] in (* TODO: use all bounds in the row *)
+    Unsat_cert.mk ~defs ~bounds
+
+  (* main satisfiability check.
+     page 15, figure 3.2 *)
+  let check_exn (self:t) : unit =
+    let exception Stop in
+    Log.debugf 5 (fun k->k "(@[simplex2.check@ %a@])" Matrix.pp self.matrix);
+
+    let m = self.matrix in
+    try
+      while true do
+        Log.debugf 50 (fun k->k "(@[simplex2.check.iter@ %a@])" Matrix.pp self.matrix);
+
+        (* basic variable that doesn't respect its bound *)
+        let x_i, is_lower, bnd = match find_basic_var_ self with
+          | Some (x, `Lower, bnd) -> x, true, bnd
+          | Some (x, `Upper, bnd) -> x, false, bnd
+          | None -> raise_notrace Stop (* line 4: we are done *)
+        in
+
+        if is_lower then (
+          (* line 5 *)
+          let x_j =
+            match
+              find_n_basic_var_ self
+                ~f:(fun x_j ->
+                    let a_ij = Matrix.get m x_i.basic_idx x_j.idx in
+                    (Q.sign a_ij > 0 && has_upper_slack x_j) ||
+                    (Q.sign a_ij < 0 && has_lower_slack x_j))
+            with
+            | Some x -> x
+            | None ->
+              let cert = cert_of_row_ self x_i ~is_lower:true in
+              raise (E_unsat cert)
+          in
+          assert (Var_state.is_n_basic x_j);
+
+          (* line 9 *)
+          pivot_and_update self x_i x_j bnd.b_val
+        ) else (
+          (* line 10 *)
+          let x_j =
+            match
+              find_n_basic_var_ self
+                ~f:(fun x_j ->
+                    let a_ij = Matrix.get m x_i.basic_idx x_j.idx in
+                    (Q.sign a_ij < 0 && has_upper_slack x_j) ||
+                    (Q.sign a_ij > 0 && has_lower_slack x_j))
+            with
+            | Some x -> x
+            | None ->
+              let cert = cert_of_row_ self x_i ~is_lower:false in
+              raise (E_unsat cert)
+          in
+          assert (Var_state.is_n_basic x_j);
+
+          (* line 14 *)
+          pivot_and_update self x_i x_j bnd.b_val
+        )
+      done;
+    with Stop -> ()
+
+  let create () : t =
+    let self = {
+      matrix=Matrix.create();
+      vars=Vec.create();
+      var_tbl=V_map.empty;
+      bound_stack=Backtrack_stack.create();
+    } in
+    self
+
+  type result =
+    | Sat of Subst.t
+    | Unsat of unsat_cert
+
+  (* Find an epsilon that is small enough for finding a solution, yet
+     it must be positive.
+
+     {!Erat.t} values are used to turn strict bounds ([X > 0]) into
+     non-strict bounds ([X >= 0 + ε]), because the simplex algorithm
+     only deals with non-strict bounds.
+     When a solution is found, we need to turn {!Erat.t} into {!Q.t} by
+     finding a rational value that is small enough that it will fit into
+     all the intervals of [t]. This rational will be the actual value of [ε].
+  *)
+  let solve_epsilon (self:t) : Q.t =
+    let emax =
+      Iter.fold
+        (fun emax x ->
+           let {base=v; eps_factor=e_v} = x.value in
+           (* lower bound *)
+           let emax = match x.l_bound with
+             | Some {b_val={base=low;eps_factor=e_low};_} when Q.(e_v < e_low) ->
+               Q.min emax Q.((low - v) / (e_v - e_low))
+             | _ -> emax
+           in
+           (* upper bound *)
+           let emax = match x.u_bound with
+             | Some { b_val={base=upp;eps_factor=e_upp}; _} when Q.(e_v > e_upp) ->
+               min emax Q.((upp - v) / (e_v - e_upp))
+             | _ -> emax
+           in
+           emax)
+        Q.inf (Vec.to_seq self.vars)
+    in
+    if Q.compare emax Q.one >= 0 then Q.one else emax
+
+  let model_ self =
+    let eps = solve_epsilon self in
+    let subst =
+      Vec.to_seq self.vars
+      |> Iter.fold
+        (fun subst x ->
+           let {base;eps_factor} = x.value in
+           let v = Q.(base + eps * eps_factor) in
+           V_map.add x.var v subst)
+        V_map.empty
+    in
+    subst
+
+  let check (self:t) : result =
+    try
+      check_exn self;
+      let m = model_ self in
+      Sat m
+    with E_unsat c -> Unsat c
+
+  (* TODO
+
+  (* maybe invert bounds, if [c < 0] *)
+  let scale_bounds c (l,u) : bound * bound =
+    match Q.compare c Q.zero with
+      | 0 ->
+        let b = { value = Erat.zero; reason = None; } in
+        b, b
+      | n when n<0 ->
+        { u with value = Erat.mul c u.value; },
+        { l with value = Erat.mul c l.value; }
+      | _ ->
+        { l with value = Erat.mul c l.value; },
+        { u with value = Erat.mul c u.value; }
+
+
+  let check_cert (t:t) (c:cert) =
+    let x = M.get c.cert_var t.var_states |> CCOpt.get_lazy (fun()->assert false) in
+    let { value = low_x; reason = low_x_reason; } = x.l_bound in
+    let { value = up_x; reason = upp_x_reason; } = x.u_bound in
+    begin match c.cert_expr with
+      | [] ->
+        if Erat.compare low_x up_x > 0
+        then `Ok (add_to_unsat_core (add_to_unsat_core [] low_x_reason) upp_x_reason)
+        else `Bad_bounds (str_of_erat low_x, str_of_erat up_x)
+      | expr ->
+        let e0 = deref_var_ t x (Q.neg Q.one) M.empty in
+        (* compute bounds for the expression [c.cert_expr],
+           and also compute [c.cert_expr - x] to check if it's 0] *)
+        let low, low_unsat_core, up, up_unsat_core, expr_minus_x =
+          List.fold_left
+            (fun (l, luc, u, uuc, expr_minus_x) (c, y) ->
+               let y = M.get y t.var_states |> CCOpt.get_lazy (fun ()->assert false) in
+               let ly, uy = scale_bounds c (get_bounds y) in
+               assert (Erat.compare ly.value uy.value <= 0);
+               let expr_minus_x = deref_var_ t y c expr_minus_x in
+               let luc = add_to_unsat_core luc ly.reason in
+               let uuc = add_to_unsat_core uuc uy.reason in
+               Erat.sum l ly.value, luc, Erat.sum u uy.value, uuc, expr_minus_x)
+            (Erat.zero, [], Erat.zero, [], e0)
+            expr
+        in
+        (* check that the expanded expression is [x], and that
+           one of the bounds on [x] is incompatible with bounds of [c.cert_expr] *)
+        if M.is_empty expr_minus_x then (
+          if Erat.compare low_x up > 0
+          then `Ok (add_to_unsat_core up_unsat_core low_x_reason)
+          else if Erat.compare up_x low < 0
+          then `Ok (add_to_unsat_core low_unsat_core upp_x_reason)
+          else `Bad_bounds (str_of_erat low, str_of_erat up)
+        ) else `Diff_not_0 expr_minus_x
+    end
+     *)
 end